I’ll Only Dance With You


Here come Fred and Ginger…


What hasn’t been said about these two? Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers are the go-to’s of both pairs dancing and Hollywood musicals. One of these was 1936’s Swing Time, a light and airy film which was an escape for Depression-era audiences, as well as in the decades following.

The movie opens at a vaudeville show, and a dance troupe is tapping away onstage. Meanwhile, a magician, Pop Cardetti (Victor Moore) is backstage trying to get one of the stagehands interested in a card trick, but nothing doing, because it’s time for the curtain to come down. Pop is bored, though–the producer has decided that magic acts are passé, and he’s trying to fill his time.

Meanwhile, his buddy, Lucky Garnett (Fred Astaire) comes spinning off the stage and makes a beeline for the dressing room, because he’s late for his wedding. His fellow dancers don’t want him to leave, however. Since Lucky’s intended, Margaret (Betty Furness) is a society woman, they tell him he can’t get married in the trousers he’s wearing because they don’t have cuffs. Heh. Spoiler alert: They’re lying.

vlcsnap-2018-05-14-09h03m30s983By the time Lucky shoots a few crap games to soothe his feelings, the guests have all gone home and the wedding’s off. However, Margaret’s dad cuts Lucky a deal. If he can go to New York and make $25,000 dollars, he can still marry Margaret.

Lucky goes to the train station, but his dancing buddies follow him, and decide all the money he won at craps is no longer his. Such nice fellas. That means Lucky’s got twenty-five cents to his name, and he does what any self-respecting broke person does: He hops a freight train. Pop follows him, because his magic act is out, anyway.

Once in New York, Lucky and Pop have to figure out what to do. Lucky’s still in his wedding cutaway, and Pop is in dire need of cigarettes. Pop is so desperate that he tries to shove a button into a cigarette machine, and Lucky asks a young woman (Ginger Rogers) for change for a quarter. She gives it to him, and Lucky and Pop stick it in there. The machine not only gives them cigarettes, but about a dollar in change.

vlcsnap-2018-05-14-09h43m02s308So Lucky runs to get his quarter back from the lady, only she rebuffs him because she can’t find the quarter in her purse. Pop took it, but he doesn’t come clean until after the lady calls a cop, who calls her full of it.

To square himself, Lucky follows the lady into the dance academy where she’s an instructor, working with her Aunt Mabel (Helen Broderick). Her name is Penny Carroll, and she’s not too happy to see him. Naturally, Lucky pretends to know nothing about dance. Penny’s irritated at first, but Lucky wins her over, especially when he shows her what a quick study he is. Mr. Gordon (Eric Blore) thinks so too, and sets up an audition for Penny and Lucky with Mr. Simpson (Pierre Watkin), a producer.

vlcsnap-2018-05-14-22h42m23s808Only problem is, Lucky’s still broke, and Mr. Gordon wants Lucky to wear dinner dress. Penny and Aunt Mabel find Lucky playing strip piquette with a drunk Englishman trying to win his dinner clothes, and losing miserably. Penny storms off, leaving Lucky wrapped in a tablecloth.

Lucky tries to make it up to Penny by arranging an audition at Mr. Simpson’s club. They can’t dance, however, because not only is the bandleader, Ricky Romero (Georges Metaxa) jealous of Lucky, but Mr. Simpson gambled away Ricky’s contract. Long story short, Lucky wins the contract back, and he and Penny dazzle everyone.

Penny can’t figure out why Ricky doesn’t want to be alone with her, and Lucky tells Pop to stick by him. He’s still technically engaged to Margaret, and he can’t figure out how to tell Penny. Meanwhile, Penny and Aunt Mabel cook up a scheme to help Penny and Lucky pair off.

vlcsnap-2018-05-14-22h50m07s071The four of them take a drive out to the New Amsterdam. No, not the theater, but a rundown house in the country. It’s snowing and picture perfect, and Penny feels romantic. Aunt Mabel does her part, and takes Pop to see where she used to fish in the summer. Pop does his part as well, calling for Lucky and throwing a snowball at his head just as he and Penny get closer.

While they’re still out in the country, Pop lets it slip that Lucky is engaged to Margaret, and Penny turns just as icy as the snow. It doesn’t last long, however. Back in New York, Ricky proposes to Penny, but she refuses. Then Aunt Mabel dares her to go kiss Lucky, and she doesn’t refuse. Too bad Margaret shows up and Lucky gets backed into a corner.

vlcsnap-2018-05-15-00h17m56s531Swing Time is a gorgeous film. It isn’t heavy on plot and it doesn’t have to be. The production design is beautifully done up in the Art Deco style. The music is by Jerome Kern, so there are plenty of classic moments such as when Lucky sits down at the piano and plays “The Way You Look Tonight” while waiting for Penny. Penny is so entranced that she doesn’t care at first that she’s standing next to Lucky with a head full of shampoo.

Oh, Penny. And Lucky. Yes, I get the play on words. Lucky? Penny? *chortles*

I know I’m probably the billionth person to say this, but Fred and Ginger are incredible. They don’t just dance together; their dance furthers their characters. It’s not as if they turn off whatever emotions their characters feel just before the music starts. Instead, they carry into the dance as if the conversation is still going, which it is. That, combined with their utter artistry, are a small part of what makes them special and unique in film history.

That does it for my Day One. Crystal and Michaela have plenty more Fred and Ginger, with more on the way. Thanks for reading, everyone, and see you mañana!

17 thoughts on “I’ll Only Dance With You

  1. Such a fun and lovely film. I think this is their best film after Top Hat. The Fred and Ginger tap sequence at the dance school is brilliant.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Swing Time holds a special place in my heart because it’s one of the few classic films my sister and I both love. (That’s not to say she doesn’t like old movies, she just doesn’t watch them as frequently or obsessively as I do, haha.)

    What always stands out to me are George Stevens’s beautiful direction and the otherwordly musical numbers. I’m getting goosebumps just thinking about “Never Gonna Dance”!

    Thanks for writing three wonderful posts for our blogathon!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Thanks for this fine review and detailed synopsis Rebecca! It refreshed my memory. I saw this movie some years ago and I admit not liking it so much, but I should give it another try. My tastes might have change! However, I remember the beautiful deco, the costumes and thought it was quite funny that we could never see Ginger Roger and Fred Astaire kissing each other.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Wonderful post Rebecca. “Swing Time” is such a cute and delightful film that always tends to cheer me up. It’s no wonder this was considered to be one of Fred and Ginger’s greater collaborations. Thanks for participating in the blogathon, and I look forward to reading your two other posts.

    Because I’m obsessed with hosting blogathons, I’ve announced another, and you are cordially invited to join in. Here is the link.


    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.